In partnership with CBSSports.com
The place to discuss inside information, the latest rumors and scoop on the Buckeyes
Anything and everything football related that has to do with your Buckeyes
If it's football recruiting, OSU-style, it's cussed and discussed here
Talk a little Buckeye basketball with your fellow Ohio State hoopsters
Bring it here for non-sports chatter that causes spirited, informed debate.
You have no favorite boards.
The most viewed topics.
The most replied to topics.
The most up-voted topics.
The most down-voted topics.
The most up-voted posters.
The most down-voted posters.
The most followed posters.
We must fill two spots – one outside and one inside. I think that must be taken in account. Shazier is too much of a game changer on the outside. You don’t move Roby to safety cause we’re weak there. The coaching staff didn’t give us any inkling that it was possible last year. It won’t happen this year.
We need a middle linebacker for our defense to work. All of our success on the defense side of the ball over the course of the last 15 years have featured a middle linebacker. There is nothing that tells me that will change.
I came to my answer predominately by using the two factors below.
#1. SPEED. While Boren proved me wrong last year, the future of this team defense is speed. It is important in the middle as well. We have recruited this very way. We want to get to the ball with explosion.
The past two recruiting classes have been very strong, with 6 guys rated over 94 on 247. They are speed guys, with the only noted MLB (Mitchell) being a sub 4.4. All of these guys have the size to play the position effectively (within the 10 lbs that MM could add if needed).
#2. LEARNING CURVE. If you look at our successful MLB in past – Laurinitis, Hawk, Homan, Wilhelm – it was in their 2nd or 3rd year that they showed effectiveness on the field. This is the nature of the beast at LB. It is a complicated position, especially transitioning from high school to college. There are always outliers, but I am basing analysis on history.
Here are candidates I am eliminating from contention:
Luke Roberts – 6’1, 225
Mike Mitchell – 6’4, 220
Trey Johnson – 6’2, 220
Jamal Marcus – 6’2 , 225
-He was an end in high school. I believe he is an edge guy – outside all the way.
Curtis Grant – 6’3, 235
-While I hope I’m wrong, don’t think the lightbulb is going on.
So here’s who we are left with:
Cam Williams – 6’1, 225
-Son of an NFL Player, so he has the pedigree. Had 120 tackles senior year in high school. National Honor Society.
Josh Perry – 6’4, 240
-Played exclusively on the outside last year when he got in. Recorded 70 tackles his senior year. Extremely athletic – long jump, hurdles, 400.
David Perkins – 6’2, 220
-Another extremely athletic guy. Running back in high school. Had a 103 tackles – Senior year (22 for loss).
My money is on Cam Williams in the middle, with the others-Perry, Perkins and Marcus, battling for outside job.
Perhaps Grant didn't actually "lose" the job. After all, Klein was a senior - and Boren was another.... We all know how Tressel and staff (see Fickell) loved them some seniors. If such was the case, Grant may be a very angry man.
he wouldn't let his players pose in the Playboy All-American magazine edition, he said, "Cause you can't play football with an erection."
You really have me scratching my head after reading this.
We return two starters at safety, landed the best DB class in the country and one of the best safeties. Who even hinted at moving a CB who is a future first round draft choice to safety? I'm sure this isn't even a topic during coaches meetings.
I think you're to fast to eliminate Mitchell and Johnson. Everything I have heard about Johnson is "student of the game". He's the one freshman I think has the best chance to come in and make an impact. He's smart and will learn quick plus we need two LBs. I think Mitchell and Johnson are going to get early playing time and if they grasp what is going on, I think they will be starters before to long. As fast as Boren stepped in and made a difference, I can't see eliminating Mitchell and Johnson as first year starters at some point.
Perkins is to small to play in the middle and Perry is an OLB all the way.
Grant will get first crack at it. In all essence the job is his to lose first.....no doubt. TJ and Mitchell will both get a crack, but Grant will get the most reps with the 1's this spring...
Everyone realizes this is contradictory right?
Senior over freshman at quarterback is what I meant. Grant was the starter before Klein was suspended. Meyer and Fickell both said that in order for the defense to be what they want they needed Grant to be the starter.
I think we should move Grant to DE. It's not happening at LB. To not even see flashes is alarming.
I'm not ready to count out any of the freshmen (now soph) LBs from last with the exception of Luke Robert. I look for either Boom Perkins or Camren Williams to step up and take the spot. I know Duane is not a fan of him because he is a drag down tackler, but I love his instincts He's the type of player that I think needed to RS. I think Trey Johnson has a great chance to get in the rotation with his football knowledge. While I think Mitchell will be a good one, I don't think he plays that much as a freshmen.
I agree with Urban that we need to recruit players who can step in right away, but not everyone is going to be physically ready to make an impact. I'm excited for camp to start.
This post was edited by Pula 86 17 months ago
Cleveland Orchestra Baby!! World's greatest!! The Brown's wet dream is to be them. The Ohio State University-Where the Illibuck Lives!
Marcus is built like a brick s--t house.
However he is another example of the staff trying to turn a defensive end/athlete into turn into a football player.
If Grant doesn't turn the corner, I would give the edge to Luke Roberts. The staff was impressed with his instincts last year in practices and he'll have one full year on any of the incoming freshman.
What are the chances Mitchell or Johnson start? Neither is enrolled yet, so they'll be getting in later this year. Seems like it would be tough. Is moving Shazier to MLB a possibility?
The Father, The Son... well, it's the
The Holy Trinity... as I see it.
247Sports In partnership with CBS Sports