Online Now 3190

The Front Row

The place to discuss inside information, the latest rumors and scoop on the Buckeyes

On this Board 1435
Record: 6110 (2/14/2012)

Online now 3144
Record: 10904 (2/4/2012)

Boards ▾

The Front Row

The place to discuss inside information, the latest rumors and scoop on the Buckeyes

Around the 'Shoe

Anything and everything football related that has to do with your Buckeyes

The Best Damn Recruiting Board

If it's football recruiting, OSU-style, it's cussed and discussed here

Bucknutin' But Net

Talk a little Buckeye basketball with your fellow Ohio State hoopsters

The Bucknuts Hot Spot

The place to be for topics too hot for any place else

The Buckeye Babe Thread

Share your favorite pix, a special lady in your life or someone else's life

Reply

Tebow Comments on Ohio State

  • Tripol said...

    This is brilliant. Maybe the most insightful conversation about Tebow I have seen to date. I love Playmea's explanation and distinction between evangelical and evangelizing. I feel people don't make that distinction enough.

    The truth is it has become common place to stereotype individuals by their religion. This happens to all religious groups way too much. There is a tremendous amount of diversity in the Christian, Jewish, and Muslim communities. Taking the time to make those distinctions and look at people as individuals with individual rights take a lot of effort. Sadly, most folks, including people in these religious communities, are intellectually lazy and would rather sit back and paint with the broad brush. It is an "us vs. them" mentality. They are wrong in their beliefs, so I am superior. People will live in their own world and cast judgment on others to hide their own inferiority complex. It is sad. It is also why the Constitution protects religious freedom.

    I simply don’t understand how Tebow taking a knee or Warner pointing to the sky is offensive? Why do people take these things so personally? Oh, wait a minute; anyone who does differently than I would in public is wrong. Then follow the above logic.

    Bigotry is alive and well.

    So disliking Tebow, his antics, or hearing a lil' speech having having to do with his religious
    beliefs in every interview is bigotry? So be it. I don't take offense at it, I just find it nauseating, To each his own. I could just as easily argue that a lot of Christians, when you don't agree with everything they believe, feel you're persecuting them.

    There is a reason I dislike a lot of what I view as "contemporary Christianity" and it's not rooted in intellectual laziness. It's the product of a lot of observation, thought, even reading, believe it or not. I'm not gonna get into it here. Again, it's about venue, this isn't the forum for it. Honestly, I violated one of my rules when I posted on this topic, and I regret it. This is self defense at this point.

    This is a total side issue, it wasn't the point of my OP, but I'd argue that there's a much broader definition of "evangelizing" than you imply. Ironically, I think the deeply evangelical Tebows would agree that constantly "bearing witness" publicly is a form of evangelism.

    As for that bigot accusation, you mentioned that it's alive and well within religious groups.
    I can vouch for that. I've witnessed plenty, some of it pretty shocking. Can I make sweeping stereotypes or paint with a broad brush? No, but I can definitely tell you it was rooted in thier fundamentalist beliefs, so that street definitely runs both ways.

    This post was edited by killabru on 5/18/2012 at 3:36 AM

    killabru

  • This entire thread is a microcosm of evangelicalism. Belief is Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior is a polarizing thing, primarily because it's either all true or entirely false. Either Jesus died on the cross for the sins of mankind, or He was some idiot who was killed for claiming to be God.

    If it's all true then people like Tebow can't possibly put their faith out there enough, because if Jesus is real then so are Heaven and Hell.

    If its all false then people like Tebow are to be pitied, and yes, ridiculed for throwing some stupid lifestyle in everyone's face.

    I find it perfectly normal that most people either love Tebow or can't stand him.

    Jeyrod8

  • yoderdame said...

    I'm not a fan cause he's a phony and I know this first hand. He's embraced this fake holier than though image created by the media and it makes me want to puke. I think a lot of folks who aren't fans just don't buy what everyone keeps trying to shove down their throats about him and call BS.

    I don't know him personally so I don't know first hand if he is a phony. Can you elaborate onto why he's a phony? Since it appears you aren't chummy with the guy, I'm sure you'll have no problem telling us the details and how you know?

    I would personally appreciate it. I don't like the idea of someone doing that publicly.

    signature image

    60% of the time, it works every time...

    playmea

  • killabru said...

    Saying how is that (media attention) Tebows fault, marked by multiple ??? for emphasis, certainly qualifies as a question. I answered it. Go back and reread my original post. Did I go off a little? Mebbe. It's not being PC, it's not AKIN to being PC IMO, I didn't demand that he stop. I explained why I don't like it, and I don't think saying it potentially applies to lots of displays of whatever affiliation is reaching.

    For the record, Warner and Tebow are the only two athletes in professional sports that have ever had that effect on me. It's a fine line,and they crossed it. Cross yourself when you walk up to the plate, take a QUICK knee, I don't have the same reaction, it doesn't bother me one bit. Strike a prolonged pose, that gets so much attention that a new word is created, that opposing players start mocking it, now it gets a little nauseating. I never gave Tressels group prayer circles a second thought.

    You're still not getting it. I'm not saying its "being PC". I'm saying its the same thing as asking someone else to be PC.

    So its really only with Warner and Tebow. I'm not even sure what Warner did. I really just don't care. With Tebow, I'm not sure if he is doing anything different than anyone else. I just think the fans took it and ran with it. To me thats once again not Tim's fault. He's just being him and the fans are reacting.

    Also, I have no problem with mocking it or mocking him. I thought the SNL stuff was hilarious. I just don't understand the hate. I still don't. Especially now that you explained there are other public displays of faith you have no problem with. It truly seems like your issue is how their faith affects the fans. I'm not sure that animosity is placed in the right direction there.

    signature image

    60% of the time, it works every time...

    playmea

  • Jeyrod8 said...

    This entire thread is a microcosm of evangelicalism. Belief is Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior is a polarizing thing, primarily because it's either all true or entirely false. Either Jesus died on the cross for the sins of mankind, or He was some idiot who was killed for claiming to be God.

    If it's all true then people like Tebow can't possibly put their faith out there enough, because if Jesus is real then so are Heaven and Hell.

    If its all false then people like Tebow are to be pitied, and yes, ridiculed for throwing some stupid lifestyle in everyone's face.

    I find it perfectly normal that most people either love Tebow or can't stand him.

    I guess I just don't think he's throwing it in everyone's face. I see it more as him wearing it as a badge.

    I know people who throw it in other people's faces. He's not doing that. I've known people who try to convert everyone. I don't see that with Tebow.

    Tebow's open faith has had ZERO impact on my impressions of Christianity. If anything, it may have pushed me away. But I don't think its cause for hatred or animosity.

    You don't think drawing parallels to Jesus' crucifixion is a little much???

    signature image

    60% of the time, it works every time...

    playmea

  • I don't think Tebow is a good quarterback. However I admire how he is not afraid to profess his faith. He is using the stage that he has been given to speak God's word. If you don't like it turn the channel and go watch a tv show about people murdering each other. We all are so de-sensitised about life and accept things we shouldn't accept. As far as him being a phony no one in this world is perfect.
    I came on Bucknuts today to clear my head. I lost my mom yesterday and as much as I am hurting I know she is in a better place. I am not Mr. religiuos, I am not perfect but I do believe in God, if we had more people like Tebow this crazy world would be a better place.

    jr88BRUTUS

  • jr88BRUTUS said...

    I don't think Tebow is a good quarterback. However I admire how he is not afraid to profess his faith. He is using the stage that he has been given to speak God's word. If you don't like it turn the channel and go watch a tv show about people murdering each other. We all are so de-sensitised about life and accept things we shouldn't accept. As far as him being a phony no one in this world is perfect.
    I came on Bucknuts today to clear my head. I lost my mom yesterday and as much as I am hurting I know she is in a better place. I am not Mr. religiuos, I am not perfect but I do believe in God, if we had more people like Tebow this crazy world would be a better place.

    Could not agree with you more about more Tebows would make the world a better place. There are people/media that can't accept someone who is motivated by higher principles than money, fame, and selfishness.

    I hope you and your family can find solace and comfort in your time of loss.

    PCL

  • playmea said...

    You're still not getting it. I'm not saying its "being PC". I'm saying its the same thing as asking someone else to be PC.

    So its really only with Warner and Tebow. I'm not even sure what Warner did. I really just don't care. With Tebow, I'm not sure if he is doing anything different than anyone else. I just think the fans took it and ran with it. To me thats once again not Tim's fault. He's just being him and the fans are reacting.

    Also, I have no problem with mocking it or mocking him. I thought the SNL stuff was hilarious. I just don't understand the hate. I still don't. Especially now that you explained there are other public displays of faith you have no problem with. It truly seems like your issue is how their faith affects the fans. I'm not sure that animosity is placed in the right direction there.

    OK Play, I'll concede your point on the distinction. I still don't think I'm asking him to be PC to tone it way down. I don't care what the guy does in his personal life. I don't care if he collects enough Phillipino foreskins to make a wallet. There's a reason workplaces and businesses set boundaries on certain kinds of expression. The NFL is both. It's a private enterprise and it's up to the league and the owners alone to set those boundaries, but I think they'd be wise to do so before it turns into a circus. A polarizing circus. One more example to make my point. Bible verse on the face throughout the game and post game interviews (evangelizing?). If you're good with it fine. How about TP's little Mike Vick eyeblack episode. OK? What if someone came out with Trayvon Martin on the cheekbones?

    Why does Tebow push my buttons. A few reasons. Like I've said before, I just see it as over the top grandstanding. While I give Tebow the benefit of the doubt as far as his character,
    I can't help it that he reminds of a certain type of Christian that that I've grown cynical about and wary of over the years, and I'll leave it at that. My own workplace experiences with fundamentalists and evangelicals has shaped my outlook too, no doubt.

    I can elaborate, a lot, but I'd just as soon lay this one to rest. Those discussions usually lead to scorched earth and hard feelings all around. A lot different than who should be the starter or who we should recruit. Again, I like my football to be pretty much, just about football.

    This post was edited by killabru on 5/18/2012 at 11:11 AM

    killabru

  • playmea said...

    I guess I just don't think he's throwing it in everyone's face. I see it more as him wearing it as a badge.

    I know people who throw it in other people's faces. He's not doing that. I've known people who try to convert everyone. I don't see that with Tebow.

    Tebow's open faith has had ZERO impact on my impressions of Christianity. If anything, it may have pushed me away. But I don't think its cause for hatred or animosity.

    You don't think drawing parallels to Jesus' crucifixion is a little much???

    I didn't draw any parallels from Tim to Jesus' crucifixion. Evangelicalism is the cross of Christ. It is because of the belief in what Jesus accomplished on the cross that evangelicals share their faith.

    I don't think Tebow is throwing it in anyone's face either. I was just using the terminology other posters were using. I know Christians like that too. People aren't perfect, Christians included.

    Jeyrod8

  • killabru said...

    OK Play, I'll concede your point on the distinction. I still don't think I'm asking him to be PC to tone it way down. I don't care what the guy does in his personal life. I don't care if he collects enough Phillipino foreskins to make a wallet. There's a reason workplaces and businesses set boundaries on certain kinds of expression. The NFL is both. It's a private enterprise and it's up to the league and the owners alone to set those boundaries, but I think they'd be wise to do so before it turns into a circus. A polarizing circus. One more example to make my point. Bible verse on the face throughout the game and post game interviews (evangelizing?). If you're good with it fine. How about TP's little Mike Vick eyeblack episode. OK? What if someone came out with Trayvon Martin on the cheekbones?

    Why does Tebow push my buttons. A few reasons. Like I've said before, I just see it as over the top grandstanding. While I give Tebow the benefit of the doubt as far as his character, I can't help it that he reminds of a certain type of Christian that that I've grown cynical about and wary of over the years, and I'll leave it at that. My own workplace experiences with fundamentalists and evangelicals has shaped my outlook too, no doubt.

    I can elaborate, a lot, but I'd just as soon lay this one to rest. Those discussions usually lead to scorched earth and hard feelings all around. A lot different than who should be the starter or who we should recruit. Again, I like my football to be pretty much, just about football.

    I'm sorry that some Christians have treated you poorly. Usually, that kind of treatment stems from a Christian thinking that showing the love of Christ is the same as pointing out someone else's sin. It is not. Jesus showed His love through humility and service, not through condemnation.

    Also, your foreskin wallet comment was hilarious.

    Jeyrod8

  • killabru said...

    OK Play, I'll concede your point on the distinction. I still don't think I'm asking him to be PC to tone it way down. I don't care what the guy does in his personal life. I don't care if he collects enough Phillipino foreskins to make a wallet. There's a reason workplaces and businesses set boundaries on certain kinds of expression. The NFL is both. It's a private enterprise and it's up to the league and the owners alone to set those boundaries, but I think they'd be wise to do so before it turns into a circus. A polarizing circus. One more example to make my point. Bible verse on the face throughout the game and post game interviews (evangelizing?). If you're good with it fine. How about TP's little Mike Vick eyeblack episode. OK? What if someone came out with Trayvon Martin on the cheekbones?

    Why does Tebow push my buttons. A few reasons. Like I've said before, I just see it as over the top grandstanding. While I give Tebow the benefit of the doubt as far as his character, I can't help it that he reminds of a certain type of Christian that that I've grown cynical about and wary of over the years, and I'll leave it at that. My own workplace experiences with fundamentalists and evangelicals has shaped my outlook too, no doubt.

    I can elaborate, a lot, but I'd just as soon lay this one to rest. Those discussions usually lead to scorched earth and hard feelings all around. A lot different than who should be the starter or who we should recruit. Again, I like my football to be pretty much, just about football.

    I'll try and answer according to each paragraph:

    I understand why you don't believe you are asking him to be PC. I'm not saying thats what you are doing. I'm saying that having a problem with someone openly talking about faith is really no different than having a problem with someone for not being PC. As much as I don't have a problem with Tebow's faith, I also would have no problem with a private industry putting a stop to openly talking about it. I really don't care and if the NFL determines that would be in their best interests than so be it. You won't hear me complain. I didn't care about Tebow's eye black and I didn't care about TP's. I thought from a public perception standpoint TP probably could have been smarter about it, but it didn't bother me at all. I think if someone brought attention to Trayvon Martin in a similar fashion, it would be ill advised but it wouldn't bother me. As long as these things aren't openly offense. For example, just saying "Trayvon Martin" isn't a problem for me. He could be honoring the kid. But something demonizing Trayvon Martin would be over the line. Equally, TP honoring his favorite player Vick didn't bother me. I'm an animal lover and have real issues with Vick. But someone liking him doesn't offend me. I just think they are misguided.

    I think you've finally answered. Its really based on cynicism you've developed about Christianity. Cannot dispute that. I have my own. Although I try not to let that extend to anyone open about their faith. I do think its up to Christianity as an institution to overcome that. I can understand why such cynicism would exist. Although I'm not sure its fair to put that on Tebow. I'm also not sure he's grandstanding but now its debating a matter of opinion which is pointless.

    If you think these things make football about something other than football than, IMO you're allowing yourself to get too emotional about it. By your logic, anything drawing attention to yourself takes away from football. So I would hope you are equally as vocal about most post game interviews and most celebrations. In fact, by your logic, the entire NFL is just a circus. If you were that consistent, then I would probably be hard pressed to argue with you. But so far you've really just focused on Tebow.

    signature image

    60% of the time, it works every time...

    playmea

  • Jeyrod8 said...

    Also, your foreskin wallet comment was hilarious.

    Meant to say that earlier... Kilabru, you got a laugh out of me with that one.

    signature image

    60% of the time, it works every time...

    playmea

  • In one hundred years Tim Tebow will still be talking about his Lord and Savior and I look foreward to shaking his hand.

    rengaw64

  • playmea said...

    Meant to say that earlier... Kilabru, you got a laugh out of me with that one.

    Enough said on my end...I left out the punchline from a corny old joke..if you rub it it turns into a suitcase..ba bing!

    killabru

  • killabru said...

    So disliking Tebow, his antics, or hearing a lil' speech having having to do with his religious beliefs in every interview is bigotry? So be it. I don't take offense at it, I just find it nauseating, To each his own. I could just as easily argue that a lot of Christians, when you don't agree with everything they believe, feel you're persecuting them.

    There is a reason I dislike a lot of what I view as "contemporary Christianity" and it's not rooted in intellectual laziness. It's the product of a lot of observation, thought, even reading, believe it or not. I'm not gonna get into it here. Again, it's about venue, this isn't the forum for it. Honestly, I violated one of my rules when I posted on this topic, and I regret it. This is self defense at this point.

    This is a total side issue, it wasn't the point of my OP, but I'd argue that there's a much broader definition of "evangelizing" than you imply. Ironically, I think the deeply evangelical Tebows would agree that constantly "bearing witness" publicly is a form of evangelism.

    As for that bigot accusation, you mentioned that it's alive and well within religious groups. I can vouch for that. I've witnessed plenty, some of it pretty shocking. Can I make sweeping stereotypes or paint with a broad brush? No, but I can definitely tell you it was rooted in thier fundamentalist beliefs, so that street definitely runs both ways.

    I absolutely agree it runs both ways. That was my point. People in and out of faith are guilty of bigotry. Of course, Tebow taking a knee or mentioning his faith in an interview is not bigotry because he is not ridiculing other people’s belief. He’s just identifying his.

    Furthmore, it seems to me that where race was once the most common division point for bigotry I believe religious beliefs have become even more common way to let bigotry rear its ugly face. It is really easy to ridicule people who don't have the same system of belief as you do. It is infinitely more difficult to be open minded about people and not judge them based off their religious beliefs (even if that belief is not to believe at all). And yes, with Christians it is particularly tragic because when a Christian acts like a bigot, they violate the very faith they proclaim to believe in. Yet, I see it all the time.

    I guess I’m just some crazy hippy that thinks it is pretty cool to get to know other people regardless of what they believe about god or the color of their skin. I’m not threatened by that in any way.

    Edit: Agreed, the wallet joke was drop dead hilarious.

    This post was edited by Tripol on 5/18/2012 at 3:01 PM

    "Tonight, my butt's sore." - Mike Krzyzewski 11-29-11

    Tripol

  • Tripol said...

    I absolutely agree it runs both ways. That was my point. People in and out of faith are guilty of bigotry. Of course, Tebow taking a knee or mentioning his faith in an interview is not bigotry because he is not ridiculing other people’s belief. He’s just identifying his.

    Furthmore, it seems to me that where race was once the most common division point for bigotry I believe religious beliefs have become even more common way to let bigotry rear its ugly face. It is really easy to ridicule people who don't have the same system of belief as you do. It is infinitely more difficult to be open minded about people and not judge them based off their religious beliefs (even if that belief is not to believe at all). And yes, with Christians it is particularly tragic because when a Christian acts like a bigot, they violate the very faith they proclaim to believe in. Yet, I see it all the time.

    I guess I’m just some crazy hippy that thinks it is pretty cool to get to know other people regardless of what they believe about god or the color of their skin. I’m not threatened by that in any way.

    Edit: Agreed, the wallet joke was drop dead hilarious.

    Apologies if I offended Tripol. While there are aspects of Christianity I've got significant differences with, some varieties more than others, I'm not an anti-religious or anti Christian zealot. My wife's a Christian, I'm not. I still count some of my fundamentalist ex-co workers among my friends, there are just some topics we don't delve too deeply into. It's an issue I've given lots of consideration to. I still do.

    Hindsight, I'd have limited the discussion to game day decorum, and use of the game itself and directly related activities to promote your religion, politics, causes etc.

    killabru

  • killabru said...

    Apologies if I offended Tripol. While there are aspects of Christianity I've got significant differences with, some varieties more than others, I'm not an anti-religious or anti Christian zealot. My wife's a Christian, I'm not. I still count some of my fundamentalist ex-co workers among my friends, there are just some topics we don't delve too deeply into. It's an issue I've given lots of consideration to. I still do.

    Hindsight, I'd have limited the discussion to game day decorum, and use of the game itself and directly related activities to promote your religion, politics, causes etc.

    No worries on my end brother. More than anything I just want to combat the stereotype that Christians are judgemental fundamentalist. Most of the Christians I associate with are open minded and humble. They represent their faith well without even trying. Will they engage you in theological discussion? Sure, but usually only when engaged on the topic. I love talking about theology, but again, that's the hippy coming out in me. I am really fascinated by the history of Judaism, Christianity, and Islam. Many people don't realize that the origins of all three faiths stem from the same story regarding Abram or Abraham's family. It's reads out like a 3-4,000 year old soap opera. Of course what happened with Abraham's descendants and the drama that followed shapes the course of human history and sets the tone for much of the geo-political conflicts that we have today, including the 9/11 attacks.

    "Tonight, my butt's sore." - Mike Krzyzewski 11-29-11

    Tripol