The Front Row

I think that is Play's point...it is a terrible way to evaluate someone's logic because people aren't being rated by their logic. They're being rated on the popularity of what they say. For example, you'll see 100 upvotes for someone that writes "love it!!!!!" to a link posted about Meyer. Conversely, you will see another person downvoted 100 times when they say something like "Jim Tressel was rightfully fired because (1) he lied to the NCAA and we don't need them breathing down our neck for the next 15 years he is here, and (2) it shows a complete lack of control to play ineligible players who have proven they cannot abide by the rules."