Online Now 2858

Around the 'Shoe

Anything and everything football related that has to do with your Buckeyes

On this Board 339
Record: 4078 (1/25/2013)

Online now 2057
Record: 10904 (2/4/2012)

Boards ▾

The Front Row

The place to discuss inside information, the latest rumors and scoop on the Buckeyes

Around the 'Shoe

Anything and everything football related that has to do with your Buckeyes

The Best Damn Recruiting Board

If it's football recruiting, OSU-style, it's cussed and discussed here

Bucknutin' But Net

Talk a little Buckeye basketball with your fellow Ohio State hoopsters

The Bucknuts Hot Spot

The place to be for topics too hot for any place else

The Buckeye Babe Thread

Share your favorite pix, a special lady in your life or someone else's life

Reply

Gladwell says ban College Football

  • soflabuck said...

    Nasty, I am completely against all this progressive sociery shit but it aint gonna stop it crom happening ... Football will be a niche sport or dead within 20 yrs

    Yea I hear ya. That's a fear that many have and there maybe something to it.

    I am okay with the progressive stuff, but only to a point.
    When little boys can't play football or any other sports at recess in elementary schools because the women won't let them be physical, then I am against it.

    When the cub/ boys scouts are being pressured to allow lesbian mom's serve as den mothers, I am against it. When women are on the sideline at football games commenting on who's playing the 3 technique, I am against it.

    I am sick of females trying to be football coaches on male teams and a lot of the "touchy feely shit" in areas of our lives that USED to be a man's domain.

    Men need to stand up and start saying no to this shit.
    Men need to be men and run their households, and stop pandering to broads as
    this simply drives me over the top!

    Okay, I am REALLY done venting now. And again, I ain't mad. I AM NASTY!!!

    GO BUCKS!!

    towel

    attachment

    East Coast Player Known for Knocking Fools Out One At A Time!

    BuckNasty_MD

  • BuckNasty_MD said...

    And your point is...........??

    And if they brought that shit back today, I would go and watch that too.

    clap

    LMAO!! You dont really mean that..

    stackbucks76

  • If I remember the interview correctly, Gladwell particularly highlighted head injuries (both full-blown concussions as well as continued pounding over time). Maybe in his future the pads come off and everyone watches rugby. I haven't watched a ton of it, but you don't see guys getting their heads beaten nearly as much. It won't change my mind, though, I love football and think it's here to stay for a long, long time. I do get his point about big time college football getting to the stage that it no longer truly is about students being athletes, but rather athletes often moonlighting as students. That just happened over time.

    Zeuslerus

  • soflabuck said...

    It used to be legal to feed christins to lions and people liked to watch that too

    LMAO. Got to love the Romans. Screw Bull fighting, dog fighting, Cock fighting bring back the lions! lol That's what this country needs

    signature image signature image signature image

    There is one at every party, thought that's why you invited me!

    bleedscarlet

  • Yeah, yeah lions.

    Let's feed 'em the occupy protestors

    Neptune

  • Neptune said...

    Yeah, yeah lions.

    Let's feed 'em the occupy protestors

    Yes, you do got to love the Romans. Those ass holes were bad ass!!

    I would vote that we feed the scUMmmers to the Lions. Now, I'd watch that for a dollar!!

    gun...goblue....frustrated

    East Coast Player Known for Knocking Fools Out One At A Time!

    BuckNasty_MD

  • BuckNasty_MD said...

    Gladwell is an ass at best!

    Hell Hitler and Pol Pot were thinkers too, but we ain't listening to those pricks are we? shrug

    As long as the money floweth, no one will pay one ounce of attention to this limp wrist, sissy type complaining about this country's greatest sport.

    It MUST me a slow period in the world of writing given all the shit that's going on around this world and all this clown can think of is to say "ban college football." Really?

    If you banned CFB, dude half the sports in men and women athletics would be canned. The college president's wouldn't be building campus building, college coffers/ endowments would plummet and I bet many schools would be begging from the government for more funding.

    Dude is advocating a return to the 1800s and sorry, I ain't interested! I bet most ain't interested as CFB is about business. BIG FRACKIN business. And given these tough times, CFB generates a lot of cash and keeps a ton of schools at or above break even.

    So ah, no, ass hole Gladwell. There will be no ban on CFB. Not in this or the next life time!

    no

    gun....ass holes named Malcom Gladwell.

    Excellent points. +1

    "The North shall rise again." General Meyer

    richardparker10

  • I rarely like to resort to Argumentum ad baculum and Ad hominem fallacies, but Gladwell can kiss my butt.

    He should have stopped with The Tipping Point.

    Man, football season cannot get here fast enough.

    This post was edited by miguelissimo on 5/3/2012 at 12:18 PM

    "Buckeye born and bred, a Buckeye 'til I'm dead"

    miguelissimo

  • Neptune said...

    Yeah, yeah lions.

    Let's feed 'em the occupy protestors

    +1

    signature image signature image signature image

    3ydncloudofdust

  • 3ydncloudofdust said...

    +1

    Thank you, sir.
    +1 to you, also.

    Neptune

  • Neptune said...

    Thank you, sir. +1 to you, also.

    never know though...even the lions may fiind them repulsive, at this point. what with all of make-shift latrenes and overall lack of hygene!

    signature image signature image signature image

    3ydncloudofdust

  • comparing football to dog fighting ignores some rather large and tangible differences.

    1. Football players are volunteers. They know what they are getting into. They do not have to play football.

    2. Dogs don't get to choose. Dogs don't get paid in any form. Dogs die in dogfighting commonly.

    Completely ridicullous comparison.

    "The only thing That Team Up North will be tasting this year is the salty tears of defeat" - UFM

    Gobucks187TTUN

  • Neptune said...

    Yeah, yeah lions.

    Let's feed 'em the occupy protestors

    Let's feed 'em the Wall Streeters that caused this mess...

    IndyDog

  • BuckNasty_MD said...

    Na Dude I ain't mad. I am "Nasty", hence the name.

    Just tired of people screwing (or at least trying) with the game dude. That's all.

    If Gladwell doesn't like it, then he can walk away and go do/ watch something else.

    That's all. We live in the US (not a progressive US) and there are other choices. He should respect our rights to have shit left alone.

    sarcasm

    Careful there, brother...that's what people in the South were saying 150 years ago--i.e., just 'cuz it is, that don't make it right.

    Whether we like it or not and whether we want to admit it or not, there is a "gladiator" kind of exploitation in sports (gladiators were both slaves and athletes). It's admittedly not a very fair analogy but at the same time lacking anything better, as far as an example of modern indentured servitude goes, kids getting drafted and forced to sign and play for NFL or NBA or NHL or MLB teams that may not be the best fit for them is that not unlike slaves sold on the auction block. While it's true slaves had literally no choices, kids wanting to play professionally still have very few. When was the last time a kid made a free agent-like list of demands prior to the NFL draft? Maybe Eli Manning when he announced back in 2004 he would not sign with the Chargers if they drafted him? And before that John Elway when he insisted he would not sign with the Colts if they drafted him? But at least Manning had Archie's money and Elway had the Yankees to fall back on for a year before re-entering the NFL draft. Both those guys were the #1 overall picks in their respective drafts so they had more negotiating leverage than most college players do.

    Malcolm Gladwell's just one voice and he represents a minority opinion but there are many devoted readers of the New Yorker who agree with him. There's nothing wrong with offering another perspective. But exploitation has always existed in sports and it always will. They are today's gladiators. Otherwise, he's an extraordinary writer. Not just The Tipping Point but also Outliers, which is a very insightful book. If you saw the recent 60 Minutes piece on how parents are "redshirting" kids by holding them back a year from starting kindergarten so they'll be the oldest and biggest kids in their class instead of the youngest and smallest (and not just for sports but overall maturity) and in which he was featured as an expert on the subject, you couldn't help but appreciate the man's intelligence. Read his books and you may find yourself looking at things differently than you always have and that's usually a good thing because it's about overcoming our own intolerances.

    This post was edited by iowabuckeyes on 5/4/2012 at 1:58 PM

    iowabuckeyes

  • P.S. Just as football survived the "soccer scare" of the 1970s when people were predicting football was fast becoming obsolete as America's youth were embracing and growing up with soccer as our "new" national pastime, I am confident football will outlive the Malcolm Gladwells of the world.

    iowabuckeyes

  • iowabuckeyes said...

    Careful there, brother...that's what people in the South were saying 150 years ago--i.e., just 'cuz it is, that don't make it right.

    Whether we like it or not and whether we want to admit it or not, there is a "gladiator" kind of exploitation in sports (gladiators were both slaves and athletes). It's admittedly not a very fair analogy but at the same time lacking anything better, as far as an example of modern indentured servitude goes, kids getting drafted and forced to sign and play for NFL or NBA or NHL or MLB teams that may not be the best fit for them is that not unlike slaves sold on the auction block. While it's true slaves had literally no choices, kids wanting to play professionally still have very few. When was the last time a kid made a free agent-like list of demands prior to the NFL draft? Maybe Eli Manning when he announced back in 2004 he would not sign with the Chargers if they drafted him? And before that John Elway when he insisted he would not sign with the Colts if they drafted him? But at least Manning had Archie's money and Elway had the Yankees to fall back on for a year before re-entering the NFL draft. Both those guys were the #1 overall picks in their respective drafts so they had more negotiating leverage than most college players do.

    Malcolm Gladwell's just one voice and he represents a minority opinion but there are many devoted readers of the New Yorker who agree with him. There's nothing wrong with offering another perspective. But exploitation has always existed in sports and it always will. They are today's gladiators. Otherwise, he's an extraordinary writer. Not just The Tipping Point but also Outliers, which is a very insightful book. If you saw the recent 60 Minutes piece on how parents are "redshirting" kids by holding them back a year from starting kindergarten so they'll be the oldest and biggest kids in their class instead of the youngest and smallest (and not just for sports but overall maturity) and in which he was featured as an expert on the subject, you couldn't help but appreciate the man's intelligence. Read his books and you may find yourself looking at things differently than you always have and that's usually a good thing because it's about overcoming our own intolerances.

    Points well taken. However, we should remember that not all issues can be extrapolated, so in this case in point and purely on the topic of football alone, its okay to advocate that shit get left alone.

    The issue of football is nowhere near the degree of importance as slavery or other much larger/ important topics. What Gladwell is overlooking is the fact that players WANT to play and "opt-in", so he can save us all the analysis and arguments of the existence of a disadvantaged underclass due to the state of football. I don't buy it.

    If players don't like the obvious, which is that injuries WILL occur, then they can simply walk away. Go find something else to do. No one is forcing these guys to strap it on and get after it.

    Players have to accept responsibility for themselves. Plain and simple.

    clap

    This post was edited by BuckNasty_MD on 5/4/2012 at 2:23 PM

    East Coast Player Known for Knocking Fools Out One At A Time!

    BuckNasty_MD

  • iowabuckeyes said...

    Careful there, brother...that's what people in the South were saying 150 years ago--i.e., just 'cuz it is, that don't make it right.

    Whether we like it or not and whether we want to admit it or not, there is a "gladiator" kind of exploitation in sports (gladiators were both slaves and athletes). It's admittedly not a very fair analogy but at the same time lacking anything better, as far as an example of modern indentured servitude goes, kids getting drafted and forced to sign and play for NFL or NBA or NHL or MLB teams that may not be the best fit for them is that not unlike slaves sold on the auction block. While it's true slaves had literally no choices, kids wanting to play professionally still have very few. When was the last time a kid made a free agent-like list of demands prior to the NFL draft? Maybe Eli Manning when he announced back in 2004 he would not sign with the Chargers if they drafted him? And before that John Elway when he insisted he would not sign with the Colts if they drafted him? But at least Manning had Archie's money and Elway had the Yankees to fall back on for a year before re-entering the NFL draft. Both those guys were the #1 overall picks in their respective drafts so they had more negotiating leverage than most college players do.

    Malcolm Gladwell's just one voice and he represents a minority opinion but there are many devoted readers of the New Yorker who agree with him. There's nothing wrong with offering another perspective. But exploitation has always existed in sports and it always will. They are today's gladiators. Otherwise, he's an extraordinary writer. Not just The Tipping Point but also Outliers, which is a very insightful book. If you saw the recent 60 Minutes piece on how parents are "redshirting" kids by holding them back a year from starting kindergarten so they'll be the oldest and biggest kids in their class instead of the youngest and smallest (and not just for sports but overall maturity) and in which he was featured as an expert on the subject, you couldn't help but appreciate the man's intelligence. Read his books and you may find yourself looking at things differently than you always have and that's usually a good thing because it's about overcoming our own intolerances.

    How can you call people that get free educations worth anywhere from $30K-150K slaves? No one made them do it.. no one makes professional athletes sign contracts.. no one says they have to pay sports.. I'd be a f*ckin slave if my ass was getting paid multi-million dollars a year to do it. It's not like they're going to be jailed or killed if they choose not to play the sport.. not giving people the option to play the sport is what I call f*ckin slavery and not letting colleges and franchises make money is what I call communism and I am sick of this country becoming pussified and everyone thinking they're entitled to every damn thing on God's green(blue) earth. People deserve the opportunity to choose for themselves and to provide for themselves not to have shit decided for them by government crooks and pansies who think they know better and think people won't be able to live without them(how they want it). With that f*ckin attitude we'll be real brainwashed communists slaves like the people in North Korea. What ever happened to Land of the FREE and home of the f*cking BRAVE? This is F*cking AMERICA not China, not North Korea, Not France, Not Canada, Not Greece.. it's f*cking AMERICA and if kids want to play College or Professional sports they have every right to do so. I don't want the government or any liberal quacks deciding what's best for me and my family(don't have one yet... hope the government lets me when it's that time). And FYI I'm sure as hell not a republican like you're probably guessing at this point.

    BTW the guy(author) has the right to his opinion like everybody else I just think it's a shitty one.

    This post was edited by BuckeyeCrusader on 5/4/2012 at 3:43 PM

    signature image signature image

    s

    BuckeyeCrusader

  • BuckeyeCrusader said...

    How can you call people that get free educations worth anywhere from $30K-150K slaves?

    Because for many, if they don't play college sports, what chance do they have of ever going to college? These aren't National Merit Scholars being told they have to play football, they're football players who are expected to igo to school. But ilet's me honest: it's football that got them there, not academics; and f it wasn't for football (or basketball), many of them wouldn't have gotten there on their own. And since 99% of BCS players won't ever play in the NFL, tell me: what's the value of that great $30-$150K education if they don't ever graduate so they can put it good use when they go to work carrying a briefcase instead of a helmet? The average college student takes five years to graduate and they aren't expected to play football (or basketball), which means practice and conditioning and weight training and team meetings and away games. So if most kids without all those expectations take five years, is it fair to expect football (or basketball) players to do it all faster? Or better?

    iowabuckeyes

  • BuckNasty_MD said...

    Points well taken. However, we should remember that not all issues can be extrapolated, so in this case in point and purely on the topic of football alone, its okay to advocate that shit get left alone.

    The issue of football is nowhere near the degree of importance as slavery or other much larger/ important topics. What Gladwell is overlooking is the fact that players WANT to play and "opt-in", so he can save us all the analysis and arguments of the existence of a disadvantaged underclass due to the state of football. I don't buy it.

    If players don't like the obvious, which is that injuries WILL occur, then they can simply walk away. Go find something else to do. No one is forcing these guys to strap it on and get after it.

    Players have to accept responsibility for themselves. Plain and simple.

    clap

    Except it's not that simple. Barry Sanders walked away and he was called a pussy.Charlie Ward won the Heisman and chose the NBA and was called a pussy. Ever watched North Dallas Forty? The scene where Nick Nolte's character takes out the LB and the RB who shot up his knee with cortisone because he was afraid of losing his job if he didn't play hurt? If you haven't, see the attached link. And before anyone dismisses that scene as pure Hollywood, don't forget that the semi-autographical book the movie was based on was written by Peter Gent, who played for the Cowboys and just died last year.

    Dave Duerson took his own life and brain damage was attributed as the primary cause. It's been proven that the lifespan of NFL players is shorter than the mainstream population. There are 40 year old men walking on 80 year old knees. The lure of fame and fortune that comes with professional sports is as undeniable and irresistible and potentially life threatening to young men as whiskey is to an alcoholic. You cannot expect a kid who thinks he'll live forever to think that far ahead.

    Hindsight is 20/20--50/50 with inflation--and assuming they still have their senses, I'd be willing to bet that more than a few guys who played professional football would wish they'd never picked up a football.

    Football will never be outlawed (although Teddy Roosevelt tried 100 years ago) but it can always be made safer for those who play it.

    North Dallas Forty

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d6aO4gx6FtI

    www.youtube.com

    iowabuckeyes

  • iowabuckeyes said...

    Except it's not that simple. Barry Sanders walked away and he was called a pussy.Charlie Ward won the Heisman and chose the NBA and was called a pussy. Ever watched North Dallas Forty? The scene where Nick Nolte's character takes out the LB and the RB who shot up his knee with cortisone because he was afraid of losing his job if he didn't play hurt? If you haven't, see the attached link. And before anyone dismisses that scene as pure Hollywood, don't forget that the semi-autographical book the movie was based on was written by Peter Gent, who played for the Cowboys and just died last year.

    Dave Duerson took his own life and brain damage was attributed as the primary cause. It's been proven that the lifespan of NFL players is shorter than the mainstream population. There are 40 year old men walking on 80 year old knees. The lure of fame and fortune that comes with professional sports is as undeniable and irresistible and potentially life threatening to young men as whiskey is to an alcoholic. You cannot expect a kid who thinks he'll live forever to think that far ahead.

    Hindsight is 20/20--50/50 with inflation--and assuming they still have their senses, I'd be willing to bet that more than a few guys who played professional football would wish they'd never picked up a football.

    Football will never be outlawed (although Teddy Roosevelt tried 100 years ago) but it can always be made safer for those who play it.

    My thoughts exactly IoB

    Football players, at least NFL'ers die 10 years earlier than the general population, have higher suicide rates, declare bankruptcy more. These are facts that are starting to come out and with medical advances and better tracking of information the real story is becoming more clear.

    Yes this is voluntary, and yes a FEW live a lifestyle that few of us will ever know, but it does have consequences that show up later in life that lulls some into a false sense of security.

    IndyDog

  • soflabuck said...

    It used to be legal to feed christins to lions and people liked to watch that too

    Why'd we ever stop that? I'd watch.

    In all seriousness, I am torn on this. CFB is my favorite sport by a long shot, but I won't let my kids play it (at least I don't think I will). The evidence is pretty strong and mounting that the risk is higher than anyone thought before. Losing your knees and having back pain every day is one thing, but losing your mind and becoming completely disabled is another.

    This post was edited by BucksinWA on 5/5/2012 at 11:59 AM

    BucksinWA

  • iowabuckeyes said...

    Careful there, brother...that's what people in the South were saying 150 years ago--i.e., just 'cuz it is, that don't make it right.

    Whether we like it or not and whether we want to admit it or not, there is a "gladiator" kind of exploitation in sports (gladiators were both slaves and athletes). It's admittedly not a very fair analogy but at the same time lacking anything better, as far as an example of modern indentured servitude goes, kids getting drafted and forced to sign and play for NFL or NBA or NHL or MLB teams that may not be the best fit for them is that not unlike slaves sold on the auction block. While it's true slaves had literally no choices, kids wanting to play professionally still have very few. When was the last time a kid made a free agent-like list of demands prior to the NFL draft? Maybe Eli Manning when he announced back in 2004 he would not sign with the Chargers if they drafted him? And before that John Elway when he insisted he would not sign with the Colts if they drafted him? But at least Manning had Archie's money and Elway had the Yankees to fall back on for a year before re-entering the NFL draft. Both those guys were the #1 overall picks in their respective drafts so they had more negotiating leverage than most college players do.

    Malcolm Gladwell's just one voice and he represents a minority opinion but there are many devoted readers of the New Yorker who agree with him. There's nothing wrong with offering another perspective. But exploitation has always existed in sports and it always will. They are today's gladiators. Otherwise, he's an extraordinary writer. Not just The Tipping Point but also Outliers, which is a very insightful book. If you saw the recent 60 Minutes piece on how parents are "redshirting" kids by holding them back a year from starting kindergarten so they'll be the oldest and biggest kids in their class instead of the youngest and smallest (and not just for sports but overall maturity) and in which he was featured as an expert on the subject, you couldn't help but appreciate the man's intelligence. Read his books and you may find yourself looking at things differently than you always have and that's usually a good thing because it's about overcoming our own intolerances.

    I think there is a huge difference. We are not making them do anything this is what most kids dream of. Yes sometimes bad things happen people can get hurt but hell you can get hurt anywhere. This is a sport kids love and want to show their talents off just as much as we want to see them. I know it wasn't exactly what you were saying but If thats how you feel then I would assume its the same for all sports. I guess if I was going to get hurt I would rather it be from doing something that I love other than what I was forced to do.

    Dotav