Online Now 2498

The Best Damn Recruiting Board

If it's football recruiting, OSU-style, it's cussed and discussed here

On this Board 73
Record: 1990 (4/21/2012)

Online now 2421
Record: 10904 (2/4/2012)

Boards ▾

The Front Row

The place to discuss inside information, the latest rumors and scoop on the Buckeyes

Around the 'Shoe

Anything and everything football related that has to do with your Buckeyes

The Best Damn Recruiting Board

If it's football recruiting, OSU-style, it's cussed and discussed here

Bucknutin' But Net

Talk a little Buckeye basketball with your fellow Ohio State hoopsters

The Bucknuts Hot Spot

The place to be for topics too hot for any place else

The Buckeye Babe Thread

Share your favorite pix, a special lady in your life or someone else's life

Reply

Derrick Green

  • Razorback said...

    Well, that's not necessarily the case -- word is that Rod just isn't picking things up very quickly. I've even seen tidbits here and there on the blogs and comment boards that Dunn may have passed him on the depth chart. What we'll have to watch for is whether the pecking order includes 3 backs and if Rod isn't one of them then you know he's just been passed. But if we're just seeing Hyde / Hall playing, then you're probably right in that they just don't want to involve a 3rd back for whatever reason. I suspect Dunn will play though. Meyer has said it a few different times in his post-practice pressers.

    I really had high hopes for Rod...hope he gets it by fall camp.

    Yea tell me about it.

    Remember back in the day when there were "collective woodies" on this board with regard to Rod Smith?
    There were flat out delusions about this kid being Eddy George & Earl Campbell all wrapped into one bad muthafracka that could out play Archie Griffen!

    Damn were the insiders and those claiming to know this kid from the hinter lands of Indiana wrong about this one? shrug

    Not saying that it can't happen eventually, BUT if the rumor of him getting passed on the depth chart and dropping down to the 4th place back are true, I wouldn't bet on this kid's rise!

    There is still time. Just not much time left for him to make his mark.

    I think I heard someone say on this board and I think that it fits:

    IF a pup is gonna bite, he's gonna bite early and bite hard! Not sure this bodes well for young Mr. Smith!

    no

    This post was edited by BuckNasty_MD on 4/19/2012 at 1:19 PM

    East Coast Player Known for Knocking Fools Out One At A Time!

    BuckNasty_MD

  • BuckNasty_MD said...

    Yea tell me about it.

    Remember back in the day when there were "collective woodies" on this board with regard to Rod Smith? There were flat out delusions about this kid being Eddy George & Earl Campbell all wrapped into one bad muthafracka that could out play Archie Griffen!

    Damn were the insiders and those claiming to know this kid from the hinter lands of Indiana wrong about this one? shrug

    Not saying that it can't happen eventually, BUT if the rumor of him getting passed on the depth chart and dropping down to the 4th place back are true, I wouldn't bet on this kid's rise!

    There is still time. Just not much time left for him to make his mark.

    I think I heard someone say on this board and I think that it fits:

    IF a pup is gonna bite, he's gonna bite early and bite hard! Not sure this bodes well for young Mr. Smith!

    no

    Ya if he turns out a flop that will be really sad. Kid's got the size and power. Clearly he's done well in the weight room, but just isn't picking the plays up or something. One thing I'm curious about is how his fumblitis is going. Hopefully that's not still present because that will derail you from carrying the ball at all.

    Razorback

  • Rem said...

    Wow, so all of a sudden we are trailing for his signature after being his favorite since the begining of his recruitment. Guess the Elliot commitment scared him off a bit, but if you think about it we do have a stable of studs in our backfield! Intresting to see how this play out, any predictions? Go Bucks!

    No -- I think is just enjoying the once in a lifetime recruiting trips and attention. I believe he said as much in one of the the many interviews being reported. He probably just likes messing with people like yourself that hang on every word he says. If he was afraid of competition then why Clemson? They signed another RB for their 2013 class. Why go there if that was really the issue. I don't think it is.
    Green was quoted as saying that he spoke to the OSU coaches AFTER Elliot committed as was assured that we were taking 2 RBs and they wanted him to be in the class. I believe he is just having fun at your expense and at the expense of every one of us that lurks on all the website's trying to figure out were these kids are going.
    I don't think he is afraid of Elliot--if your a top 5th or 6th RB in the nation, you don't cower when a lesser RB is on the team because you know he is not better than you.

    This post was edited by buckstopshere on 4/19/2012 at 2:47 PM

    buckstopshere

  • buckstopshere said...

    No -- I think is just enjoying the once in a lifetime recruiting trips and attention. I believe he said as much in one of the the many interviews being reported. He probably just likes messing with people like yourself that hang on every word he says. If he was afraid of competition then why Clemson? They signed another RB for their 2013 class. Why go there if that was really the issue. I don't think it is. Green was quoted as saying that he spoke to the OSU coaches AFTER Elliot committed as was assured that we were taking 2 RBs and they wanted him to be in the class. I believe he is just having fun at your expense and at the expense of every one of us that lurks on all the website's trying to figure out were these kids are going. I don't think he is afraid of Elliot--if your a top 5th or 6th RB in the nation, you don't cower when a lesser RB is on the team because you know he is not better than you.

    More clarity, from from Buckstopshere............

    clap

    Great job young grass hopper! I agree with your sentiments.

    GO BUCKS!!

    East Coast Player Known for Knocking Fools Out One At A Time!

    BuckNasty_MD

  • Rem said...

    Wow, so all of a sudden we are trailing for his signature after being his favorite since the begining of his recruitment. Guess the Elliot commitment scared him off a bit, but if you think about it we do have a stable of studs in our backfield! Intresting to see how this play out, any predictions? Go Bucks!

    Chill guy! Don't believe everything you read.

    signature image

    The brave don't live long but Cowards don't live at All!

    underdog

  • Really sad that a kid who dreamed of being a buckeye, and gets an offer, maybe misses out. Don't know if it was just a matter of convincing himself or others convincing him that he had enough time and should look around. Seemed odd to me that he threw out a 2013 announcement date with the number of RB offers out there. But looks like he maybe out in the cold and needing to come to realization he has to consider other schools seriously.

    If he isn't a buckeye- its going to be tough on him watching Grant (his buddy he convinced go the OSU) win a national title.

    ILbuck1

  • ILbuck1 said...

    Really sad that a kid who dreamed of being a buckeye, and gets an offer, maybe misses out. Don't know if it was just a matter of convincing himself or others convincing him that he had enough time and should look around. Seemed odd to me that he threw out a 2013 announcement date with the number of RB offers out there. But looks like he maybe out in the cold and needing to come to realization he has to consider other schools seriously.

    If he isn't a buckeye- its going to be tough on him watching Grant (his buddy he convinced go the OSU) win a national title.

    Well he could call Coach Meyer and commit tonight. shrug

    What's stopping him? He has an offer and if he was that pressed about being a Buck and the things you mention he could end the drama now. End it tonight.

    Why has he been screwing about with the likes of Clemson and VT? Just read a post that said he's headed to VT's spring scrimmage. This doesn't sound like a kid that wants to be a Buckeye when things are getting kicked off pretty hard in C-Bus.

    If it were me, I would have arrived on campus in C-Bus yesterday and been sitting in the parking lot when Coach Meyer and staff arrived for work Friday morning at 7AM.

    It's called perseverance and doing what you have to do to get what you want.

    My man Malcom X called it.........."BY ANY MEANS NECESSARY!!!"

    Starting to think Green is a flake and not interested in being a Buckeye. His actions say enough to me and there's nothing about his reported approach that indicates that he knows that the Buckeye train is leaving the station. So I say forget about him. Time to move on as he's not all that interested in playing for a winner.

    Let him take his ass to Clemson and end up in a basketball conference playing for a tier 3 ball club!

    Time to move on!!no

    GO BUCKS!!

    This post was edited by BuckNasty_MD on 4/20/2012 at 8:36 PM

    attachment

    East Coast Player Known for Knocking Fools Out One At A Time!

    BuckNasty_MD

  • Was he supposed to come to our spring game orginally? Last minute change to go to the VT game?

    Razorback

  • I totally agree with your thoughts on D. Green, BuckNasty_MD. There's a lot more guys available if we're going to take another RB. Heck, we could look to David Williams or Ryan Green to fill the scholarship. I really like both of them.

    HawaiiBuck

  • IMO, rb is not a big need this year. I think Ball is going to turn some heads in the fall.

    dkbuckeyes

  • buckstopshere said...

    No -- I think is just enjoying the once in a lifetime recruiting trips and attention. I believe he said as much in one of the the many interviews being reported. He probably just likes messing with people like yourself that hang on every word he says. If he was afraid of competition then why Clemson? They signed another RB for their 2013 class. Why go there if that was really the issue. I don't think it is. Green was quoted as saying that he spoke to the OSU coaches AFTER Elliot committed as was assured that we were taking 2 RBs and they wanted him to be in the class. I believe he is just having fun at your expense and at the expense of every one of us that lurks on all the website's trying to figure out were these kids are going. I don't think he is afraid of Elliot--if your a top 5th or 6th RB in the nation, you don't cower when a lesser RB is on the team because you know he is not better than you.

    No-- Im not hanging on every word he says. Bucknuts did a front page report on the kid stating Green has a new leader. No disecting involved. Why Clemson you say? Why not? The competition at TOSU is superior to Clemson. We have a stable of 4 and 5 star backs. Clemson simply does not. Like i said before interesting how this plays. Hope he is wearing the scarlet and grey. Go Bucks!!!

    signature image signature image signature image

    Rem

  • Because Green helped convince Curtis Grant to become a Buckeye, I'll always welcome him. If he decides there is just to much competition for the ball at OSU and goes elsewhere....so be it. In Urban's mode of "everyone competes for everything" he probably would not see the field. I would much rather have Rod Smith have a great spring game and then work into the starting rotation. Last year's offense was a clusterfiretruck and really the backs were at a huge disadvantage. The new QB's and WR's were just running around trying to remember what to do; the O-line was a mess; and the opposing teams quickly learned to stack the box to shut down the run. I doubt that any RB in the country would have performed well in that situation. So let's give Rod a " do-over" and see what develops. As for Green, if he isn't willing to prove he is better than all the rest, then he should go elsewhere. Even Green's idol, Eddie George, had a tough start and had to earn his way back on the field.

    siksikaua

  • Agree he has probably decided there are better situations for playing time and he is exploring those options. But even in the best case where he goes to Clemson and is a first rounder - he s going to have regrets when he sees OSU in national title games

    Should have verbaled early when he had the chance to his dream school - get the process over early.

    ILbuck1

  • siksikaua said...

    I doubt that any RB in the country would have performed well in that situation.

    I thought Boom looked pretty good last season

    Anyone know if he showed up with his HS coach or not?

    BuckGuy1

  • iowabuckeyes said...

    We have 9 in, which leaves us maybe 11 spots open in a class of 20, which is based on having only 81 now, 15 seniors and losing probably 4 to attrition. Here's how this class seems to be shaking out:

    QB: none in, need 1 (Barrett or Bailey but not both), maybe 2 (Chapman, Trubisky) RB: 1 in, maybe 1 more (Green, Clement, Williams, Isaac, Mizell, others) OL: 1 in, need at least 2 more, maybe 3 more (Pocic, Lazard, Montellus, Johnson, others?) TE: 1 in, maybe 1 more (Heuerman or McNeil) WR/ATH/playmaker: 1 in, maybe 2 more (Shelton, Quick, Allen, North, Treadwell, Foster) DE/DT: 2 in, maybe 2 more (Bosa, Hurst, Bower, Daniel, Poggi, Munger, Sherit, Neal) LB: none in, need at least 2 (Smith, Anzalone, Love, Kimbrough, Levenberry, others?) DB: 3 in, maybe 1-2 more (Cravens, Day, Alexander, Bell)

    Top Priorities: OL (2), LB (2), QB (1) and WR (1). That's at least 6 right there, minimally, maybe as many as 9. Not priorities: RB, TE, DL, DB.

    Sometimes, in order to get something, you have to give up something, e.g., if Bosa commits, what/who are we willing to give up? If we don't get Heuerman or McNeil, what are we losing since TE's not a priority position?

    At some point, Urban's going to faced with the old "bird in hand = two in the bush" dilemma--does he take a kid he knows he can get today or does he hedge his bets and hold off for a 5-star who won't make his decisions until January or even NSD? Does he take a 5-star at a non-priority position (Bosa) and then give up one at a priority position (QB, OL, LB)?

    Or do we see more roster attrition, instead of maybe four guys leaving for different reasons, could it be as many as 9 so we get a class of 25 again?

    This is where it really starts to get interesting. And it's only mid-April.

    Iowa
    I appreciate how analytic you are, but I would tweak your logic here.
    QBs no more
    WRs 2 or 3 Gibson will commit leaving one or two more Hopefully Foster and Quick
    TEs 1 Heuerman will commit probably leaving McNeill out
    OLs 1 or 2 Posic hopefully Maybe Montelus Johnson probably to PSU
    DL 3 SSDE Bosa, LEO Neal, and One DT The first to commit Probably Hurst
    LB 1 or 2 Love or Kimbrough, and Smith if persuaded
    DBs 2 or 3 Bell, maybe Thomas can be flipped,Worley, outside chance of Cravens or Alexander, and only last minute settling on Day

    Class can not be over 20 unless mass exodus, but I can not see why too many kids would want to leave this program with the excitement brewing. Unless there are grade problems, medical issues, or disciplinary problems which I believe are going to taper off this year.
    Kenny Hayes may have gained too much weight to carry his knees. Chris Carter may not find enough PT. Too early to tell about anyone else. No Juniors will transfer out with only one year left.

    This post has been edited 2 times, most recently by Catdaddyh on 4/22/2012 at 4:08 AM

    Catdaddyh

  • It is obvious that none of you guys have EVER been down South to visit any of these campuses, because Clemson and VT especially are two Beautiful places to live. Playing Football is NOT the #1 purpose in life, and should NOT be the focus in life, and #1 consideration in deciding one path and direction in one young man';s future. Sure we are all HOMERS here in Buckeye Nation, and I for one did not even go to OSU myself. I wanted to get away from home. There are other Beautiful campuses around the Country, and those two are two Beautiful campuses. Take it from me.

    D Green seems to be like Diggs last year, or even Diamond. Sort of like a "what have you done for me lately?'"
    I would not be waiting on the fence post for him anytime soon. Let him go.
    We have such a young stable of backs here for a long time coming.
    Jordan is a Senior
    Carlos is a Junioir
    Rod is a Soph
    Brionte is a Freshmen
    Warren is a Reshirt
    Elliott is in the Barn
    Why do we need any more?
    There is more coming in 2014
    Dymonte Thomas wants to play RB doesn't he?
    Lets flip him and give him a shot at RB, before putting him back where he belongs at SS!

    Catdaddyh

  • Catdaddyh said...

    It is obvious that none of you guys have EVER been down South to visit any of these campuses, because Clemson and VT especially are two Beautiful places to live. Playing Football is NOT the #1 purpose in life, and should NOT be the focus in life, and #1 consideration in deciding one path and direction in one young man';s future. Sure we are all HOMERS here in Buckeye Nation, and I for one did not even go to OSU myself. I wanted to get away from home. There are other Beautiful campuses around the Country, and those two are two Beautiful campuses. Take it from me.

    D Green seems to be like Diggs last year, or even Diamond. Sort of like a "what have you done for me lately?'" I would not be waiting on the fence post for him anytime soon. Let him go. We have such a young stable of backs here for a long time coming. Jordan is a Senior Carlos is a Junioir Rod is a Soph Brionte is a Freshmen Warren is a Reshirt Elliott is in the Barn Why do we need any more? There is more coming in 2014 Dymonte Thomas wants to play RB doesn't he? Lets flip him and give him a shot at RB, before putting him back where he belongs at SS!

    Catdaddyh, I live in Virginia and my good buddy is a bigtime VT booster. He invites me to games every year. I usually go to the thursday night games so I won't miss the Bucks. The stone buildings are beautiful , the campus small, tha stadium WAY overrated. If you believe for one second that these other things matter to a football player the caliber of Green I will have to disagree. He is not going to become an engineer, he is going to play football and try to make the league. The ACC is not the best place to do that. I really believe that the amount of running backs on the Bucks roster is causing him some concern and I can appreciate that. However I do believe he wanted to be a Buckeye and now has doubts as to his playing time. I hope he comes to Columbus and becomes a great back for us. He is good!

    LoudounVabuck

  • Catdaddyh said...

    Iowa I appreciate how analytic you are, but I would tweak your logic here. QBs no more WRs 2 or 3 Gibson will commit leaving one or two more Hopefully Foster and Quick TEs 1 Heuerman will commit probably leaving McNeill out OLs 1 or 2 Posic hopefully Maybe Montelus Johnson probably to PSU DL 3 SSDE Bosa, LEO Neal, and One DT The first to commit Probably Hurst LB 1 or 2 Love or Kimbrough, and Smith if persuaded DBs 2 or 3 Bell, maybe Thomas can be flipped,Worley, outside chance of Cravens or Alexander, and only last minute settling on Day

    Class can not be over 20 unless mass exodus, but I can not see why too many kids would want to leave this program with the excitement brewing. Unless there are grade problems, medical issues, or disciplinary problems which I believe are going to taper off this year. Kenny Hayes may have gained too much weight to carry his knees. Chris Carter may not find enough PT. Too early to tell about anyone else. No Juniors will transfer out with only one year left.

    I wrote that list before Barrett and Anzalone committed so I'm not sure which part of my logic you're tweaking. My point was--and still is--that we don't have an unlimited # of options so Urban needs to be judicious with the few spots that are left, which is now down to 5 and we still only have one OL commitment. Either that or he's got to find a way to drop some ballast. I think 20's realistic and agree anything more than that's a push unless...

    Montelus committed to ND yesterday, as did Lazard to WVU. That's two off the list. According to Rivals, we've only offered 12 OLs and 8 of them have already committed (including Lisle to OSU). That leaves 4 to fill at least 2 spots. The OL offer pipeline needs to be refilled.

    I am a big fan of defensive line depth but stocking up there shouldn't come at the expense of the OL. We need at least 2, if not 3. I am confident they will come...in time. These are the guys coaches need to see in action, going pad to pad against guys their own size, which most of them don't get to do in HS where a 6-6/280 OT may outweigh a DE by 70 pounds, which is hardly the level of competition they'll face in college. The summer camp in June will go a long way in that regard, not just toward 2013 but 2014.

    Kids choose to leave because they're not playing, they're homesick or they're encouraged to leave. See Jordan Sibert and J.D. Weatherspoon as two recent examples.

    iowabuckeyes

  • Catdaddyh said...

    It is obvious that none of you guys have EVER been down South to visit any of these campuses, because Clemson and VT especially are two Beautiful places to live. Playing Football is NOT the #1 purpose in life, and should NOT be the focus in life, and #1 consideration in deciding one path and direction in one young man';s future. Sure we are all HOMERS here in Buckeye Nation, and I for one did not even go to OSU myself. I wanted to get away from home. There are other Beautiful campuses around the Country, and those two are two Beautiful campuses. Take it from me.

    D Green seems to be like Diggs last year, or even Diamond. Sort of like a "what have you done for me lately?'" I would not be waiting on the fence post for him anytime soon. Let him go. We have such a young stable of backs here for a long time coming. Jordan is a Senior Carlos is a Junioir Rod is a Soph Brionte is a Freshmen Warren is a Reshirt Elliott is in the Barn Why do we need any more? There is more coming in 2014 Dymonte Thomas wants to play RB doesn't he? Lets flip him and give him a shot at RB, before putting him back where he belongs at SS!

    I see what your saying, but I'll have to respectfully disagree. A 17 year old high schooler doesnt care how pretty a campus is. They care about winning programs that can give them an opportunity to play in the league.

    signature image signature image signature image

    Rem

  • I am all for running back depth and how it is a "flashy" topic! He stated early on Ohio State was his leader and he wanted to be just like Eddie George and now he tweets that Michigan would be hard to say no to!? Any Buckeye that I want on my team could say no to Michigan very easily.If you are a true Buckeye it would be easy... just say NO! Or if you are the shy type tell Hoke there is a Hometown Buffet behind him and when he turns to look run away! Problem solved!

    We need to concentrate on filling scholarships with playmaking wideouts and offensive linemen! flex

    deeustin89

  • deeustin89 said...

    I am all for running back depth and how it is a "flashy" topic! He stated early on Ohio State was his leader and he wanted to be just like Eddie George and now he tweets that Michigan would be hard to say no to!? Any Buckeye that I want on my team could say no to Michigan very easily.If you are a true Buckeye it would be easy... just say NO! Or if you are the shy type tell Hoke there is a Hometown Buffet behind him and when he turns to look run away! Problem solved!

    We need to concentrate on filling scholarships with playmaking wideouts and offensive linemen! flex

    http://www.osusilverbullet.com/4/post/2012/04/recruit-talk-derrick-green.html

    signature image signature image signature image

    There is one at every party, thought that's why you invited me!

    bleedscarlet

  • He said we once led but it all even now. We are still recruiting him and no one leads. Seems to be in no hurry hopefully he can visit in the future. Friday Night Lights would be cool,jmo

    signature image signature image signature image

    There is one at every party, thought that's why you invited me!

    bleedscarlet