-
csoto47 said...
I agree that one's religion should not be open to scruitiny but let's face it, in politics, everything is fair game. I remember the newspapers asking if you, the voter could vote for a Catholic when John Kennedy ran for President. Some were concerned that he would take "orders" from the Vatican. I believe the problems many have with Obama is not just his religion but so many other facets of his life which are, for whatever reasons, unknown. He is not very forthcoming about his academic files including his college grades or papers. Princeton has also sealed Michelle Obama's file. Birthers will always feel they have a case because of so much conflicting information that they feel has not been adequately answered. In the end, it is the Democratic Party which vetted him and submitted Obama as qualified to be a Presidential candidate, so they bear the burden in the future if Obama turns out to be unqualified for the office which he now holds. So, whether he is Muslim or not, there is enough doubt and causes some to wonder what else is there about Obama that might not be what it appears. Religion is the least of his problems and shouldn't be a concern those who support him. Unfortunately, the same cannot be said for Mitt Romney and to a lesser degree, R. Santorum.
-
Urban_Meyer
- 4 stars Rating: 77
1602 votes total - 2 National Championships and counting... the Big Ten won't know what hit them.
- (1021)
- 18 months
- Send Message
- Follow User
- Ignore User
- 4 stars
-
ericgobucks said...
And I'm an atheist. I respect religions, but there are nuts jobs of every stripe. They all make me nervous. Look at Koresh, the Michigan Militia, McVeigh, etc. All Christians. No religion is free from extremism.
I would also love to see churches get back to feeding the poor and helping those in need instead of being proxies to political parties. It benefits no one. No political party has a corner on "god."
-
Urban_Meyer said...
The attorney general has the final say as to whether a candidate actually meets the qualifications to be president, not their political party. If Obama really was born in Kenya and wasn't an American citizen as birthers love to accuse, then the election would not have been certified and he wouldn't be president right now. If people want to believe that there was some conspiracy involving the attorney general to get a guy who isn't an American citizen elected, then there is nothing anyone can say that will change their minds.
The truth is that all political candidates, including Obama, hide things from the public or make promises that they know they can't keep because the average voter is dumb and gullible enough to actually believe and subsequently vote for them. Politics is a dirty game and in order to get to the top everyone has to get some dirt on them although they need to appear clean to get the votes of the crowd that is stupid enough to believe that they will actually carry through on the ridiculous promises they make with total integrity and innocence.
-
BuckeyeDog
- 5 stars Rating: 97
5635 votes total - Boodie Champion- If you can't Fugg it, or Eat it, Pizz on it!
- (2784)
- 27 months
- Send Message
- Follow User
- Ignore User
- 5 stars
-
ericgobucks said...
This is the perfect example of "vague" criticisms of Obama that aren't even saying anything. I respect your right to express yourself, but your complaint is that "too many things [about Obama] are unknown. What does that mean?
How come no one on the right talks about him using all of Bush's financial guys? How about doubling down on Afghanistan when the reports coming out where disastrous? Both, in my opinion, are very serious issues. How about increasing drone attacks around the world including targeting an American citizen in Yemen? That is a sticky legal situation, regardless of what he was accused of (and very likely was doing). Those are concrete criticisms.
How much about Bush did we know? The Republicans hid Bush's DUI in Texas. How about them hiding the fact he was a deserter from the Air National Guard? His drug use, his alcoholism and irresponsibility even as a full grown man with a family are all serious issues of character and judgement.
By electing George W. Bush in 2000 and 2004, the right can no longer win an argument on the facts. I hope he was worth it, because now you guys lost the moral high ground on spending, the economy, and the phony cultural issues. It is a tall price to pay for 2 terms.
-
csoto47 said...
I don't disagree with your post because I know how dirty politics can be. The Attorney General may certify a candidate qualifications but that information comes from the party that forwards his name as a candidate. So they in fact do the legwork, the AG puts his or her imprimatur on it. Personally, I am not a "birther" because I believe there is no upside to either political party placing a candidate that would eventually be found unqualified. So much would be lost and the losing party would suffer consequences for years. It is a wonder that we citizens can muster enough faith in any one person to lead our nation given the nature of politics and it's sullied reputation. I think we have become more cynical over the years and our vote is not so much as one of confidence as it is one of hope. We have been deceived and cheated by those who have taken an oath to serve us and now seek to make the citizens of this nation, in fact, subservient. IMO.
Urban_Meyer
- 4 stars Rating: 77
1602 votes total - 2 National Championships and counting... the Big Ten won't know what hit them.
- (1021)
- 18 months
- Send Message
- Follow User
- Ignore User
- 4 stars
-
Jake 23 said...
All of these people might have claimed to be christians, but they hardly acted like a true christian should. Good Christians do not blow up federal buildings like McVeigh, have a violent standoff with the ATF like Koresh, or behave like the Michigan Militia. The point is that none of these people behaved or lived their lives like a true Christian should. I ask you to not condemn entire religions based on the actions of a few. With that said, I want to talk about tOSU sports and not politics.
Urban_Meyer
- 4 stars Rating: 77
1602 votes total - 2 National Championships and counting... the Big Ten won't know what hit them.
- (1021)
- 18 months
- Send Message
- Follow User
- Ignore User
- 4 stars
-
arny769 said...
Oh the "Christians and Jews did it too" argument. Yeah they did it...a long fricking time ago. The blind belief that being critical of Islam and the terrorist fanaticism is equivalent to lumping all Muslims together and thus being a bigot for it is a very narrow minded opinion popularized by the left leaning. The truth is that the Fanatics take the Muslim world hostage. Their maniacal "stand with or you die like an infidel" scares most of the countries into being pacified to their abhorrent attacks or even sympathizing with them (9/11 was actually the US bombing ourselves!!!!!!). There lies the problem and the critical analysis of the so called bigoted opinion. Whether our reactions to Terrorism is wrong or not does not justify an "apology to the Muslim world tour" as some of our left leaning Dems loved to do. The problem exists and it is very black and white right now. Kill the infidel at all costs so he succumbs to the sword of Islam. We need help from our Muslim friends and we are not getting it is what it boils down to. Look at Pakistan for example. What is an expected outcome with a public bible burning vs a public Koran burning? Just ask Salman Rushdie or Theo van Gogh. It's incredibly safe to be critical of Religions that don't have a large and organized fanatical wing that pretty much has carte blanche to kill as they please. Al Qaeda, like any good professional company, has Mission Statement that people should read....it will open your eyes. This is were Ron Paul has some very good points as well when it comes to our political meddling being a galvanizing battle cry for them. But that is where it ends because the war has been declared and you can't take back past meddling.
As for the critical analysis of Obama being a Muslim is really only a slice of what the real problem that a great deal of us have. The real problem is "Who is this guy?". His background is so jumbled and murky that led a good deal of us just asking the question and not really getting a clear cut answer. It could be his camp was so arrogant that such criticism was dealt in long drawn out fashion but it is still not the way to answer questions that American Public would like to know. Transparency has not been the strong suit of this Administration even they he said that would happen. I just look at the attempted reduction to retired Military benefits as an example of behind-the-scenes maneuvering that is being personally led Obama's inner circle.
Just trying to clarify some opposing opinions and also express how frustrated some of us are to be Lumped into "General Right Wing Cry Baby Bigoted Complainists"...which do exist and give us a bad name....Moderate Rational Thinking people.
Urban_Meyer
- 4 stars Rating: 77
1602 votes total - 2 National Championships and counting... the Big Ten won't know what hit them.
- (1021)
- 18 months
- Send Message
- Follow User
- Ignore User
- 4 stars
-
csoto47 said...
"Vague" is the operative word here, eric. I was stating the concerns of Obama's critics who believe that in spite of his promise to be transparent, there are too many holes in the fabric of the politician which seem to be present in the personal side. That is one reason he is losing the support of some key segments of his base. I have heard them and so have you. I am not the one who promised to be transparent nor can I answer for him or his critics. I was pointing out the doubts and criticisms that are out there. If you want me to be specific, I can and will but I would not tell you anything you haven't heard already. Your may have mistaken my being attempt at brevity for being "vague". Again, asking questions or criticisms about Obama always evoke an anti-Bush response as though that carries any weight. Not every Republican nor conservative was a Bush fan and for the record I am a registered Dem with conservative values.
-
Urban_Meyer said...
One thing that really annoys me about the far right these days is that they accuse Obama of being a Muslim as if it is some sort of crime. Last time I checked the Constitution specifically states that there can be no religious test for a president, so what's the big deal? If Obama was in fact a Muslim and had a press conference to announce it, there would be nothing conservatives could do but stomp around and be angry because Obama has every right to be whatever religion he likes. It seems to me that the constant accusations of Obama being a Muslim or being from Kenya are nothing more than thinly veiled racism and bigotry because no one ever accused Bush of being from another country and the big difference between he and Obama is that he's white and Obama is black and therefore racists claim he's not a citizen or that he's a Muslim because they know they can't get away with saying that they're pissed because we have a black guy as president. It's really sad that Obama has to make a media event out of going to church because people refuse to believe he's a Christian and even after he does they still refuse to believe it.
Obama has many flaws and people are right to criticize him for his real or perceived failures, but this never-ending religion issue is ridiculous and goes against the very Constitution that so many conservatives claim to love and revere so much. So my question after all of that is, what's the big deal with Obama's religion?
-
arny769 said...
Oh the "Christians and Jews did it too" argument. Yeah they did it...a long fricking time ago. The blind belief that being critical of Islam and the terrorist fanaticism is equivalent to lumping all Muslims together and thus being a bigot for it is a very narrow minded opinion popularized by the left leaning. The truth is that the Fanatics take the Muslim world hostage. Their maniacal "stand with or you die like an infidel" scares most of the countries into being pacified to their abhorrent attacks or even sympathizing with them (9/11 was actually the US bombing ourselves!!!!!!). There lies the problem and the critical analysis of the so called bigoted opinion. Whether our reactions to Terrorism is wrong or not does not justify an "apology to the Muslim world tour" as some of our left leaning Dems loved to do. The problem exists and it is very black and white right now. Kill the infidel at all costs so he succumbs to the sword of Islam. We need help from our Muslim friends and we are not getting it is what it boils down to. Look at Pakistan for example. What is an expected outcome with a public bible burning vs a public Koran burning? Just ask Salman Rushdie or Theo van Gogh. It's incredibly safe to be critical of Religions that don't have a large and organized fanatical wing that pretty much has carte blanche to kill as they please. Al Qaeda, like any good professional company, has Mission Statement that people should read....it will open your eyes. This is were Ron Paul has some very good points as well when it comes to our political meddling being a galvanizing battle cry for them. But that is where it ends because the war has been declared and you can't take back past meddling.
As for the critical analysis of Obama being a Muslim is really only a slice of what the real problem that a great deal of us have. The real problem is "Who is this guy?". His background is so jumbled and murky that led a good deal of us just asking the question and not really getting a clear cut answer. It could be his camp was so arrogant that such criticism was dealt in long drawn out fashion but it is still not the way to answer questions that American Public would like to know. Transparency has not been the strong suit of this Administration even they he said that would happen. I just look at the attempted reduction to retired Military benefits as an example of behind-the-scenes maneuvering that is being personally led Obama's inner circle.
Just trying to clarify some opposing opinions and also express how frustrated some of us are to be Lumped into "General Right Wing Cry Baby Bigoted Complainists"...which do exist and give us a bad name....Moderate Rational Thinking people.
foubazzi ●
- 4 stars Rating: 79
2808 votes total - Fouad Bazzi
- (2230)
- 27 months
- Send Message
- Follow User
- Ignore User
- 4 stars
-
Urban_Meyer said...
One thing that really annoys me about the far right these days is that they accuse Obama of being a Muslim as if it is some sort of crime. Last time I checked the Constitution specifically states that there can be no religious test for a president, so what's the big deal? If Obama was in fact a Muslim and had a press conference to announce it, there would be nothing conservatives could do but stomp around and be angry because Obama has every right to be whatever religion he likes. It seems to me that the constant accusations of Obama being a Muslim or being from Kenya are nothing more than thinly veiled racism and bigotry because no one ever accused Bush of being from another country and the big difference between he and Obama is that he's white and Obama is black and therefore racists claim he's not a citizen or that he's a Muslim because they know they can't get away with saying that they're pissed because we have a black guy as president. It's really sad that Obama has to make a media event out of going to church because people refuse to believe he's a Christian and even after he does they still refuse to believe it.
Obama has many flaws and people are right to criticize him for his real or perceived failures, but this never-ending religion issue is ridiculous and goes against the very Constitution that so many conservatives claim to love and revere so much. So my question after all of that is, what's the big deal with Obama's religion?
Buckeye Warrior ●
- 4 stars Rating: 78
14513 votes total - (13852)
- 27 months
- Send Message
- Follow User
- Ignore User
- 4 stars
-
Urban_Meyer said...
Do you realize that many of the people who criticize Obama's religion and call him a Muslim are white too? Just because they voted for him in 2008 doesn't mean they can't change their minds, and there's always the sizeable percentage that did not vote for him in the first place. Just because most white people voted for him doesn't mean there aren't any racists out there who get attention by screaming louder than everyone else.
minsterbuckeye
- 4 stars Rating: 62
5722 votes total - (4015)
- 27 months
- Send Message
- Follow User
- Ignore User
- 4 stars
-
minsterbuckeye
- 4 stars Rating: 62
5722 votes total - (4015)
- 27 months
- Send Message
- Follow User
- Ignore User
- 4 stars
-
ericgobucks said...
And I'm an atheist. I respect religions, but there are nuts jobs of every stripe. They all make me nervous. Look at Koresh, the Michigan Militia, McVeigh, etc. All Christians. No religion is free from extremism.
I would also love to see churches get back to feeding the poor and helping those in need instead of being proxies to political parties. It benefits no one. No political party has a corner on "god."
-
Urban_Meyer
- 4 stars Rating: 77
1602 votes total - 2 National Championships and counting... the Big Ten won't know what hit them.
- (1021)
- 18 months
- Send Message
- Follow User
- Ignore User
- 4 stars
-
Urban_Meyer said...
I am a moderate but I am focusing on the right because 1) They are far more influential than any liberal group (despite what any right-wing conspiracy theorist thinks), and 2) You don't see liberals making such a huge issue of the religion of candidates in their elections. The far left, despite what many conservatives think, does not exist as an influential group in this country. If you want true socialism, go to Europe, but as for here it has no influence. The Democrats are a center-right party and Obama reflects that in many of his policies that have angered a lot of liberals.
Just because I am a moderate doesn't mean I don't have problems with both liberals and conservatives but the reality of the political situation in this country is that conservatives have far more influence than liberals and so most people are going to concentrate on them.
-
Jkmds said...
This is the issue. Being critical of "the terrorist fanaticism" is not lumping all Muslims together. Being critical of "Islam" in general absolutely IS lumping all Muslims together. Your very statement seems to suggest that 1) you acknowledge that these are two separate things, and 2) you're critical of both of them. Maybe that was just poor wording, and if so I apologize for calling you out, but I hear very similar comments fairly routinely and can’t help but notice the inconsistency...
I do think it’s a little ironic you point out some of the conspiracy theorizing that takes place in the Muslim world regarding 9/11 as though it’s demonstrative of their problems in a thread discussing the fact that a significant portion of the US population believes our President is a secret Muslim. Maybe we shouldn’t be casting the first stone on the conspiracy theory issue ;)
Christianity and Judaism have been developing for quite a bit longer than Islam has, and both have populations based mostly in developed nations, which I think is key. You say a long time ago, but there are plenty of “Christians” in parts of Africa today who are just as barbaric as the worst Muslim extremists out there. A lot of these problems have more to do with societal issues than religious ones.
I also have never understood the whole “NO APOLOGY” stance. If I make a mistake in my personal life that hurts someone, I apologize for it. If I make a mistake at work that causes a mess for someone else, I apologize for it. Hell, if one of my friends is acting like an idiot I end up apologizing for it sometimes even when I didn’t actually do anything wrong. That’s not weakness; it’s acknowledging that something I did (or that someone in my circle did) caused problems for someone else and that I will try to avoid that in the future. We’ve killed hundreds of thousands of people, many of them completely innocent. I fail to see why apologizing for that is inappropriate.
This post was edited by arny769 on 2/23/2012 at 10:28 AM
-
Urban_Meyer
- 4 stars Rating: 77
1602 votes total - 2 National Championships and counting... the Big Ten won't know what hit them.
- (1021)
- 18 months
- Send Message
- Follow User
- Ignore User
- 4 stars
- Post a New Topic
- Back to Topics
- « Previous Topic
- Next Topic »
- Boards ▾
- Pages: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | ... | 8








Let's say Obama is in fact a Muslim: So what?